I’ve spent more hours than I’d like to admit wrestling with underground monsters otherwise known as tree roots. If you’ve ever tried to clear a garden bed only to hit a “wall” of wood, you know exactly how frustrating it is.
You need the right gear, or you’re just going to end up with a sore back and a broken shovel. Finding the best garden tools for removing tree roots is about more than just brute force; it’s about having the right edge and leverage for the job.
Not all tools are created equal when it comes to the dirty work of excavation. Some are meant for soft soil, while others are built to bite through solid oak.
What Are the Best Garden Tools for Removing Tree Roots?
When you’re facing a massive root system, you need a variety of tools to handle different stages of the process. You can’t just rely on one thing. You need a tool to dig, a tool to cut, and a tool to pry. If you try to do it all with a standard garden spade, you’re going to have a very long weekend.
1. The Root Slayer Shovel
This is probably the most revolutionary tool for this specific task. Unlike a traditional round-point shovel, a Root Slayer has a heavy-duty “V” shaped tip with serrated edges. It’s designed to slice through roots as you push it into the ground.
It acts as both a shovel and a saw. When you hit a root, you don’t have to stop and grab another tool. You just apply a bit of pressure, and the teeth do the work. It’s a complete game-changer for anyone dealing with thick, matted root systems in heavy soil.
2. Heavy-Duty Mattocks and Pickaxes
If you are dealing with incredibly hard, compacted soil or very large roots, the mattock is your best friend. A mattock has a long handle with a head that features a vertical axe blade on one side and a horizontal adze on the other. It’s built for swinging and breaking things apart.
The axe side is perfect for chopping through thick roots once you’ve cleared the dirt away. The adze side helps you scoop out the loosened soil. It provides incredible leverage that a handheld tool simply cannot match. It’s a workout, sure, but it’s effective.
3. Reciprocating Saws (The “Sawzall”)
For the really big stuff that a shovel won’t touch, you need power. A reciprocating saw equipped with a “wood with nails” or a dedicated “pruning” blade is a beast. You can stick the blade right into the dirt (though it will dull the blade eventually) to cut through roots that are several inches thick.
It saves an immense amount of physical energy. Instead of hacking away with an axe for ten minutes, the saw zips through in seconds. Just make sure you clear as much dirt away as possible first to keep the blade sharp for longer. According to Family Handyman, using a pruning blade on a reciprocating saw is one of the fastest ways to manage underground wood.
4. Digging Bars
Sometimes, the root isn’t just stuck; it’s anchored deep. A digging bar is a long, heavy piece of solid steel, usually five to six feet long. It has a pointed end and a flat, chisel-like end. This tool is all about weight and leverage.
You use the weight of the bar to drive the chisel end into the root or the ground around it. Once it’s wedged in, you can use the length of the bar to pry the root upward. It’s the ultimate tool for “popping” a stump out of its hole once the main lateral roots are cut.
Why You Need Specialized Tools for Roots?
You might be wondering why you can’t just use what’s already in your garage. The truth is, tree roots are incredibly dense and often covered in abrasive soil. Standard tools aren’t built for that kind of abuse.
Avoiding Tool Damage
If you use a regular garden lopper on a root that’s covered in sand, you will ruin the blade in minutes. Specialized root tools often use hardened steel that can handle the friction of dirt. They are built to be sharpened frequently because the manufacturers know they’re going to get beaten up.
Saving Your Body
Digging out a tree is one of the most physically demanding tasks in landscaping. Using the best garden tools for removing tree roots reduces the amount of repetitive, high-impact force your joints have to absorb. Leverage-based tools like the digging bar do the heavy lifting so your lower back doesn’t have to.
Speed and Efficiency
Time is money, or at least it’s time you could be spending relaxing. A job that takes four hours with a spade might take forty-five minutes with a mattock and a reciprocating saw. It’s about working smarter, not harder.
How to Choose the Right Tool for Your Project?
Not every root problem requires a motorized saw or a six-foot steel bar. You need to assess the situation before you start buying gear. If you’re just clearing small feeder roots for a flower bed, a hand-held root saw might be plenty.
Assess the Tree Size
The size of the tree usually dictates the size of the root system. For a small sapling, a simple root-cutting shovel is usually enough. For an old oak or maple stump, you’re going to need the whole arsenal—mattock, saw, and prying bar.
Soil Composition
If you live in an area with heavy clay, tools with thinner profiles are better because they cut through the “sticky” soil more easily. In rocky soil, you want heavy steel like a pickaxe that won’t bend or chip when it hits a stone. Understanding your “dirt type” is key to picking the right blade.
Proximity to Structures
If the roots are near a foundation or a pipe, you have to be careful. You can’t just go swinging a mattock wildly. In these cases, precision tools like a hand-held root knife or a small reciprocating saw are much safer. They allow you to see exactly what you are cutting.
Step-by-Step Guide to Removing Tree Roots Safely
Once you have your gear, you need a plan. Don’t just start hacking at the ground. There is a method to the madness that will save you a lot of sweat.
-
Expose the Root: Use your shovel to clear away the top layer of soil. You need to see the “skeleton” of the root system before you start cutting.
-
Identify Main Laterals: Look for the thickest roots spreading out from the center. These are the anchors.
-
Cut the Extremities: Use your Root Slayer or saw to cut the roots about two feet away from the trunk first. This makes the center part easier to wiggle.
-
Use Leverage: Once the outer cuts are made, use your digging bar to try to lift the root. If it won’t budge, look for a “tap root” going straight down.
-
The Final Cut: Cut the tap root if there is one. This is usually the hardest part, and where the reciprocating saw shines.
-
Backfill: Never leave a hole in your yard. Fill it with a mix of soil and compost to ensure the ground doesn’t sink later.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Digging Out Roots
Even with the best garden tools for removing tree roots, things can go wrong. I’ve seen people make some pretty big blunders that ended up costing them a lot of money in repairs.
Cutting Utility Lines
This is the big one. Always call your local utility marking service before you dig deep. It’s usually a free service, and it prevents you from slicing through a gas line or an internet cable. No root is worth a neighborhood blackout.
Using the Wrong Blade
Don’t use a fine-tooth wood saw on roots. The dirt will dull it instantly, and the wet wood will gum up the teeth. Always use “demolition” or “pruning” blades. They have large gullets that clear out the debris as they cut.
Ignoring Safety Gear
Steel-toed boots are a must. When you are swinging a heavy mattock or prying with a steel bar, your feet are in the “splash zone.” A pair of heavy gloves will also prevent the inevitable blisters that come from hours of digging.
Manual vs. Power Tools: Which Is Better?
There’s a debate in the gardening community about whether manual tools are better than power tools. Honestly, it depends on your physical condition and the scale of the job.
The Case for Manual Tools
Manual tools like the mattock or the Root Slayer give you more control. You can “feel” when you hit a rock or a pipe. They are also quieter and don’t require batteries or gas. For many, the physical labor is part of the satisfaction of gardening.
The Case for Power Tools
If you have ten stumps to remove, manual labor is going to break you. Power tools like reciprocating saws or even rented stump grinders are essential for large-scale clearing. They turn a grueling task into a manageable project. According to Bob Vila, renting a stump grinder is often more cost-effective than buying multiple high-end manual tools for a one-time job.
Essential Accessories for Root Removal
Beyond the cutting tools, a few accessories make the job much smoother. Don’t overlook these when you are prepping your gear list.
-
A Sharpener: Roots are abrasive. You’ll want a simple mill file to touch up the edges of your shovels and mattocks every hour or so.
-
A Root Hook: This is a small, claw-like tool that helps you pull smaller roots out of the dirt once they are cut. It saves your fingers from getting cramped.
-
Heavy Duty Tarp: When you dig a big hole, you end up with a mountain of dirt. Putting it on a tarp makes it much easier to slide back into the hole when you’re finished.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a chainsaw to cut roots?
Technically, yes, but I wouldn’t recommend it. Dirt will ruin a chainsaw chain almost instantly. Unless you have a specific “demolition” chain and don’t mind the mess, stick to a reciprocating saw.
How deep do I need to go?
Most surface roots that cause trip hazards or interfere with mowing are in the top 6 to 12 inches of soil. If you are removing a stump, you may need to go 2 to 3 feet deep to clear the main structure.
Will the roots grow back?
If you leave a large portion of the root system intact, some species (like Willows or Poplars) might send up “suckers” or new shoots. It’s best to remove as much of the main root mass as possible or use a root killer on the remaining ends.
Final Thoughts on Root Removal Tools
At the end of the day, the best garden tools for removing tree roots are the ones that fit your specific yard and your physical ability. If I had to pick just two, I’d go with a serrated root shovel and a solid mattock. Those two will handle 90% of what a typical homeowner faces.
Remember, this kind of work is a marathon, not a sprint. Take your time, clear the dirt so you can see what you’re doing, and let the tools do the heavy lifting. There is a massive sense of accomplishment when you finally pull that stubborn root out of the ground. It’s about taking back control of your landscape.